NextGenLinks Review: Why I No Longer use NextGenLinks One-way Link Service

I Cancelled NextGenLinks. Here’s Why.

Posted on 05. Mar, 2009 by joefission in Link Building, Reviews

NextGenLinks looked really promising. And I still believe that it is promising. It’s just not for me. It was a tough decision, as I love link-building services, but I just didn’t feel the service was worth the effort. There are so many services competing for money right now that you really have to cherry pick what fits your business the best. That said, I’m sure it’s perfect for the right person, but until they clean up their inventory and mature the service, I’m going to pass on it.

The NextGenLinks Concept

For SEO purposes, building hundreds of links pointing only to your site’s home page doesn’t look very organic; nor do 100 links with the same anchor text. So generally speaking, when you begin building backlinks to your site, you build 50 percent of the links to your home page with varying anchor text; you build the remaining 50 percent to your top inside pages, again varying the anchor text. Fifty percent of the links will have your primary keyword, with the other 50 percent consisting of the remaining long-tails that you’ve uncovered.

NextGenLinks address this SEO concern with a system that builds as many links to inside pages as your home page. Because most sites have “money” pages with your best offers, you can also designate bonus URL’s that will get more links than other pages in the system. It also addresses the problem of relevance by making sure that links in and out are contextually relevant to the source or target.

How NextGenLinks Works

Your first step when you join is to add your domains. I had a gold account, so I decided to load it up with 30 domains of varying types. I had a number of blogs, some conduit review sites, a StoreStacker, a few Build a Niche stores, and a few AdSense sites.

After you add your domains, you spider them with their contextual spider. What really should have been a one-click process — say a “Spider Domains” button — was a painful 48-hour exercise in frustration. Their spider has some serious problems, which I briefly mention below.

Once your domains are spidered, you grab your PHP snippet. You can either grab PHP code directly, or you can download a sidebar widget that you can add to your widget-enabled Wordpress blogs. You can place the snippet wherever you like, but it seemed to look best in the sidebar, in a 120×600 or 160×600 layout. You can define the width, but just setting it to 100% meant that it would fill your entire column, matching your layout better. You can also customize the colors in your PHP snippet so that it matches your blog, much like you can style an AdSense ad.

Finally, you individually go to each of your domains in the system and approve outbound links from your pages. You can submit up to 8 links per day per domain, but I wasn’t able to determine how your outbound links affected your inbound links. For example, outbound link building was so tedious (explained below) that I ended up with 40 inbound and 2 outbound links after a week.

So for an automated link-building service, it requires quite a bit of effort. And that effort is ongoing, as all outbound links have to be created manually. I don’t believe that’s necessarily a bad thing, as I like knowing that I can prevent links to bad neighborhoods, but it’s too cumbersome to do so. The way it works is you select each domain and then select the page from which you want to link. NextGenLinks will then identify contextual matches for those pages that you can review and approve.

This contextual matching feature is pretty slick. Most link-building services will match on a domain; but NextGenLinks takes this a step further and matches on the content of a specific page. For example, on one of my cell phone blogs, I had an article posted about the link between cancer and cell phone use. This post attracted a link from a cancer blog. That makes a heck of a lot of sense and adds to the organic presentation of the linking service.

I should also mention that inbound linking can be automatic or manual, whichever you choose. NextGenLinks recommends automatic inbound links, but after reviewing my first 8 inbound links (junk), I decided to manually review them. I ended up rejecting about 50 percent of the link requests, and only got one link that I would consider a good backlink.

The Advantages of NextGenLinks

NextGenLinks is engineered very well. In fact, in terms of site quality, feature forethought, and intuitive usability, it’s one of the easiest to use sites I’ve seen in quite some time. The dashboard views are excellent, both from a design and coding standpoint. But there are some irksome problems underneath the hood (see next section). Overall, I was very impressed with the service and its usability.

You control your outbound links, so you can link to whomever you want. If you don’t want to link to a new PR0 blog, then don’t. Your outbound links are also contextually relevant, giving a very organic appearance to them.
Your inbound links are contextually relevant on a page-by-page basis. This is absoluetly golden.
Your links grow very naturally over time.
You can specify bonus URL’s to receive extra inbound link love, which again is very organic.
You can build links to every single page of your site or blog.
You can link out from only those pages you choose. For example, if you want to keep your homepage or your offer page clean, then do son. You control not just to whom you link, but from where you link.

The Problems I Have with NextGenLinks

Really, this is not an automated link-building service; it’s simply a link facilitation service. It will help you manage your n-way link exchanges, that’s all — it won’t handle them for you. That might be just what the doctor ordered for many people, but I was looking for what was billed on the box: automated, relevant links.

This next problem is not the fault of NextGenLinks, as it just isn’t mature enough yet to have a large inventory of sites, but I was inundated with junk inbound link requests. After the first 8, I turned off the auto-approve feature so that I could review them. Six of the first eight were from the same page on one site — I don’t know why I’d want six backlinks from one source, even if they do point to different pages. I’d rather use my allotment (there’s got to be some kind of allotment check) on different sources.

Several of my inbound links were from dynamic pages that had nothing on them but an error message. Pages get into the system via the spider, and then the owner must approve the outbound links, so the owner knows that he submitted a junk link, but once it’s approved (or auto-approved), you can’t get rid of it.

Out of all of the links I received (about 40 over a week), only one was what I would consider high-quality. There is a lot of AdSense junk in the system right now. I couldn’t find any sites whose numbers were comparable to mine in terms of PR and traffic, and I didn’t even add my flagship domains into the system.

Another minor issue is that there doesn’t seem to be any protection against reciprocal links. That is, I could link out to someone who had already linked into me. I didn’t try to link to a page that already linked to me, so I can’t speak to that, but there was no domain check.

The spider is terrible. Just terrible. The web-based spider is slow as molasses, and often didn’t spider the same domain similarly on different runs. Sometimes only a third of the pages would be indexed, sometimes hundreds (literally) of external pages were spidered. One of the spidering sessions took a good 12 hours to run. Six of my sites couldn’t be spidered at all — it just kept returning 0 URL’s.

There is also a downloadable spider, but it unfortunately generates zero-length CSV’s, at least at the time of this writing. Finally, you have another option: you can add URL’s individually. You need to enter a title, a description, keywords, and other relevant words. You can also fetch these from the meta tags, but there is a threading issue and it seems that the Ajax calls start to trip on each other. It doesn’t matter anyway, because the response times on the server are so slow that it often takes several minutes to perform one action. They have got to move this thing to a bigger cluster. For the limited number of members they have right now, that performance can only be explained by hosting this on a VPS account. Even a single dedicated server would have been appreciably faster.

And finally, to get the last ounce of frustration out of my stem: the UI is Flash-based. That means that the best browser innovation in recent years, tabs, cannot be used to speed up the perceived responsiveness of this process. Instead, you are treated to popups, and popups that popup other popups. It’s all very linear and entirely frustrating.

The Bottom Line

NextGenLinks looks to be a very promising service. I know I mentioned quite a few negatives above, but in reality, much of those are the types of problems that will plague any new service.

While it’s certainly not automated by any stretch, being able to facilitate an n-way link exchange with relevant properties is gold. Especially when you consider that you can build links to inside pages as well.

But I suspect there will be some growing pains. They need more users and a bigger site inventory; they need to provide some community guidance to prevent webmasters from linking out from bad pages; they need some kind of quality guidelines or checks in place. Speaking of checks, they need some kind of reciprocal link alert or prevention function.

Considering that I was able to build 40 links to 30 sites in about 5 days time, I’d day there is enormous potential here to generate a consistent flow of relevant inbound links. Unfortunately, this flow requires a little too much effort for my taste. Time is always at a premium, and is usually the number one factor I consider when making a decision. With the number of link-building services competing for my wallet, there are others that meet my needs a bit better.

That’s why I cancelled my subscription.

Tags: backlinks, Link Building, NextGenLinks, product review, traffic

39 Responses to “I Cancelled NextGenLinks. Here’s Why.”

Charles

19. Mar, 2009

Hi,

I really appreciate this very honest review and I reluctantly agree with many of the items you stated.

We are going through some growing pains, no doubt, and we fully intend to overcome them and build this into the absolute best link building service on the net, period.

I am bookmarking this post and using it as a guideline to address each and every issue and before you know it, you’ll be back

I already sent the link to the programmers…

Thanks again for trying Nextgenlinks.com and for being honest…

Charles
Shaun Taylor

19. Mar, 2009

I think you’re right, Charles. I think you have a top-notch service started, and all things considered, the problems I mentioned in the post don’t go very deep.

The deciding factor for me (and it *was* a tough decision) was the speed. I’ve seen your comments on other blogs and the WF, so I have no doubt that you’ll deliver.

Thanks for stopping by.

Shaun

Shaun Taylor’s latest blog post..Ezine Articles Premium: You Can’t Schedule for Day End
Pawel

18. Aug, 2009

This is a very interesting post. I tried out some other solutions for automated link building but none of them was really satisfying. On the one hand the services was only semi-automatic. You had to do a lot by yourself and the automatation was just in posting. But this can also do a trainee. On the other hand there are services that do everything fully automatic but they don’t work very good. A real working solution isn’t in sight for me. I just use a trainee and an Excel sheet.
Bobby

30. Sep, 2009

I do a lot of SEO myself and have to admit there are some suggestions you gave here and that I had not thought of. For example, I don’t think I rotate my anchor text enough so it doesn’t look very organic.

Cheers
[Comment Policy]

08. Oct, 2009

Great review, thank you for this writeup on nextgenlinks. I’ve been reading about their service wondering if its legit or not, and your review left me with a good feeling that they are an honest company at least. Now that its almost 6 months after this post, I’d like to see if they improved anything based on your suggestions in this review.
Argao

27. Oct, 2009

I was about to sign up. Well - i just thought of looking for a review. Yours is the best review for this.

Very fair, honest, sincere, authentic… all adjectives pointing to as the best review.

Thank you.
Joe H

12. Nov, 2009

Hi, great review very detailes. I have two questions

1) Has the service improved

2) You did not give us any alternatives - any ideas as I’m really annoyed at the rubbish I get from indian link builders.

Hopefully you will respond!
Jason Tipp

02. Dec, 2009

Not interesting but also helpful text. I like when people are sharing their knowledge with others to show how money can be earned from all those internet issues. I know that a case of making blog or site popular is a tough one, and there are many ups and downs of every aspect of ti, but still I’m happy when such post appears.
Jesper

16. Dec, 2009

I seriously considering NextGenLinks, but this review made me a litlle “nervous” about the quality of the links. I love the thought about letting the software do everything on auto-pilot, but if could result in potentially harmful link, I wouldn’t want to use it. I will try to research some more, to find out if the service has improved, over the last 4-5 months.
ccna lab

09. Jan, 2010

Building backlinks is the hard part of any SEO project. But it can be an easy task if it is done correctly. By backlinking from sites on the same niche of your website, or publishing article, creating web 2.0 properties using the keywords in your niche.
Quality + relevancy + authority = Fast Ranking.

Hope this help.
Brian

13. Jan, 2010

How would this link service affect adsense sites? Would Google see NextGen as a huge footprint and shut down the adsense account?
tanda-tanda melahirkan

04. Mar, 2010

tanda-tanda melahirkan: it’s a good article for me. Keep posting sob…
kesehatan ibu dan anak

06. Mar, 2010

makna tangisan bayi hi sir…nice to read your article
dunia lucu

06. Mar, 2010

tebakan lucu: a good job sir..
Jay H

06. Mar, 2010

I agree, although people still use adsense and it’s not for me…to each their own I guess
John Philip

06. Mar, 2010

there are so many ways to make money if someone isn’t for you people need to learn to just move on
Kim T

06. Mar, 2010

Everyone needs to pick and choose carefully and learn from blog post like this…good job
Andre

20. Mar, 2010

Hi! This is so true, but You only find out, when used it and look in detail, with loads of experience. Thank You for this review. As I started to try the Free Nextgenlinks-Startpackage, I couldn´t get the snippet to run. I think because allow_url_fopen not enabled on my VPS (BTW, I really don´t want to open that service, without having talked to the Nextgenlink-People). So I tried to get in contact with them as upcoming client. Nooo chance. I mean, they are just not available. Tried it with 5 Tickets over the last two weeks. Then I got someone on the chat at their hostingservices and he was kind of helpless (pure intention) and told me, that he is just for answering questions related to hosting and gave me the WHOIS information of nextgenlinks.
Okay, that is it. No way for them to get me as client. I told him: You are the same company, make it look as it is so, and don´t answer my questions or push my tickets? Why should I buy the one or the other service?

So, Joe, not only from the technical site, this service is not recommendable. Not by me.
And to get back to Your posting, it is also not a good thing that they make it look fully automated, because then lots of people don´t review their own links, and a guy like You gets all the unreviewed crap on his network. I just can underline what You said about that service, because one thinking about it, can understand without trying. And You gave us the right thoughts. Thank You.
Andre
John Philip

02. Apr, 2010

Great review, thank you for this writeup on nextgenlinks. I’ve been reading about their service wondering if its legit or not, and your review left me with a good feeling that they are an honest company at least.
Webmind

05. Apr, 2010

Charles from NextGenLinks, it’s been a year. Can you return and give a report of how your service has improved upon all the faults mentioned in this review?

We would love to hear from you.
CCNA Labs

23. May, 2010

Thanks for the review of the service, yea it doesn’t seem much easier than just doing everything manually.
Walter White

13. Jun, 2010

D*mn, that was a good review. I expected a lot of fluff, but you got right to it and told the truth.

I’m going to check around your site to see what you have to say about some of the other services I’ve been thinking about getting.
Stacy Fordham

18. Sep, 2010

What do you think of NextGenLinks now?

Have they made the necessary changes since this review?

Thanks.
Rebecca

03. Oct, 2010

despite the complications - I am going to test on the service. My domain is only about 2-3 months old, i only have 100 backlinks, but i’m on page 4 of google.

I will try the service out - and report back in 2 weeks.

Rebecca.
Michael Hellickson

31. Jan, 2011

Can someone that has used the service recently update the current level of performance.

Some questions I think everyone would like to know are:

1. How well does the spider work now?.

2. Does the service have the ability to spin articles to make them unique for each posting?.

3. What is the average number of backlinks that stick per article?.

4. Average pr?.

Thanks in advance for any help!.
marbella hen

09. May, 2011

I have a writing and editing services company, and we currently have $4500 of our operating budget. We are planning to do direct mail marketing, advertisements in trade journals, and online marketing (pay-per-click, e-newsletters, etc). How much of my marketing budget should I allocate for online marketing.
madrid football tickets

02. Jun, 2011

Thank you for your site post. Johnson and I are actually saving for a new ebook on this issue and your post has made people like us to save our money. Your ideas really solved all our concerns. In fact, more than what we had known prior to when we stumbled on your great blog.
commercial construction west palm beach

24. Jun, 2011

I need a link to a site that shows the statistics of the 3 new consoles and a description about it. They can be 2 seperate links but I would prefer 1. thank you
Yong Brancanto

07. Jul, 2011

That is the appropriate weblog for anyone who needs to seek out out about this topic. You notice a lot its virtually onerous to argue with you (not that I truly would need…HaHa). You undoubtedly put a brand new spin on a topic thats been written about for years. Great stuff, just nice!
Trudy

14. Jul, 2011

Gosh, I wish I would have had that inrfomatoin earlier!
Rental in Cannes

04. Aug, 2011

It is really a great post submit here.Nice stuff by author really.keep it up.
A-Rated windows

04. Aug, 2011

When i start to read this post then my interest goes on increase when i was going on move forward.
floor paints

05. Aug, 2011

Thanks to provide such a nice post.I like this post very much.
Lauren Cruz

22. Aug, 2011

Themelis Cuiper’s SocialGarden Biz events : advertising & social media advertising had a book mark to your text. Any idea why? So your feed is example of something.
MetaStock data

17. Oct, 2011

if the page has good information or sticks to the topic, there is a possibility that it can have a good page rank. It might not be worth the time, but who knows what might happen? There is a chance that they could make a difference. Just put effort into the site to get a good page rank.
oven cleaners

29. Oct, 2011

Miley Cyrus is a mess. And I surely would never have put my daughter in Hollywood read Disney. The entertainment industry has a huge chunk of responsibility for taking our kids down the drain, but you will never, ever hear them take one bit of responsibility for it. Thanks
Door signs

03. Nov, 2011

if u want an xbox 360, a ps3 or a nintendo wii for free, now u can, wheres the catch? u ask, there isnt one really, people say there is nothin for free in this life, well u dont just receive it, you must work a little but its worth it so heres what to do
rentals cannes

14. Nov, 2011

It might not be worth the time, but who knows what might happen? There is a chance that they could make a difference.
iphone app development

28. Nov, 2011

You might also search for backlink list and dofollow list, it’s probably not worthwhile to post links on noFollow sites that search engines don’t follow, which are getting to become the norm. You want to get a plugin that identifies doFollow links, firefox might be the best seo browser.thanks